bug 7243. Rewrote FixedTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths

layout/html/table/src/BasicTableLayoutStrategy.cpp

@@ -233,7 +233,8 @@ BasicTableLayoutStrategy::~BasicTableLayoutStrategy()
 }
 
 PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, 
-                                            PRInt32 aNumCols)
+                                            PRInt32 aNumCols,
+                                            nscoord aMaxWidth)
 {
 #ifdef NS_DEBUG 
   nsIFrame* tablePIF = nsnull; 
@@ -251,7 +252,7 @@ PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize,
   mCols            = mTableFrame->GetEffectiveCOLSAttribute();
 
   // Step 1 - assign the width of all fixed-width columns
-  AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths();
+  AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(aMaxWidth);
 
   // set aMaxElementSize here because we compute mMinTableWidth in AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths
   if (nsnull != aMaxElementSize) {
@@ -389,7 +390,7 @@ nscoord BasicTableLayoutStrategy::CalcHorizontalPadding(PRInt32 aColX)
 
 // Step 1 - assign the width of all fixed-width columns, all other columns get there max, 
 //          and calculate min/max table width
-PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths()
+PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aMaxWidth)
 {
   TDBG_SP("** %p: AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths **\n", mTableFrame);
   nsVoidArray *spanList    = nsnull;

layout/html/table/src/BasicTableLayoutStrategy.h

@@ -91,7 +91,7 @@ public:
     * @param aMaxElementSize  [OUT] if not null, the max element size is computed and returned in this param
     * @param aNumCols         the total number of columns in the table
     */
-  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols);
+  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols, nscoord aMaxSize);
 
   /** compute the max element size of the table.
     * assumes that Initialize has been called
@@ -123,10 +123,12 @@ protected:
     * Computes the minimum and maximum table widths. 
     * Set column width information in each column frame and in the table frame.
     *
+    * @param aMaxWidth - the computed width of the table or 
+    *  UNCONSTRAINED_SIZE if an auto width table
     * @return PR_TRUE if all is well, PR_FALSE if there was an unrecoverable error
     *
     */
-  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths();
+  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aComputedWidth);
 
   /** compute the min and max width of this table.  Assumes AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths
     * has been called.  Sets mMinTableWidth and mMaxTableWidth as a side effect.

layout/html/table/src/FixedTableLayoutStrategy.cpp

@@ -73,109 +73,135 @@ PRBool FixedTableLayoutStrategy::BalanceColumnWidths(nsIStyleContext *aTableStyl
   return result;
 }
 
-/* assign the width of all columns
+/*
+ * assign the width of all columns
  * if there is a colframe with a width attribute, use it as the column width
  * otherwise if there is a cell in the first row and it has a width attribute, use it
  *  if this cell includes a colspan, width is divided equally among spanned columns
  * otherwise the cell get a proportion of the remaining space 
  *  as determined by the table width attribute.  If no table width attribute, it gets 0 width
  */
-PRBool FixedTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths()
+PRBool FixedTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aComputedWidth)
 {
+  NS_ASSERTION(aComputedWidth != NS_UNCONSTRAINEDSIZE, "bad computed width");
   if (gsDebug==PR_TRUE) printf ("** %p: AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths **\n", mTableFrame);
-  
-  PRInt32 colIndex;
-  PRInt32 specifiedColumns=0;   // the number of columns whose width is given
-  nscoord totalWidth = 0;       // the sum of the widths of the columns whose width is given
 
-  PRBool * autoWidthColumns = new PRBool[mNumCols];
+  const nsStylePosition* tablePosition;
-  nsCRT::memset(autoWidthColumns, PR_TRUE, mNumCols*sizeof(PRBool));
+  mTableFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)tablePosition);
+  PRBool tableIsFixedWidth = eStyleUnit_Coord   == tablePosition->mWidth.GetUnit() ||
+                             eStyleUnit_Percent == tablePosition->mWidth.GetUnit();
+
+  const nsStyleSpacing* tableSpacing;
+  mTableFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Spacing, (const nsStyleStruct*&)tableSpacing);
+  nsMargin borderPadding;
+  tableSpacing->CalcBorderPaddingFor(mTableFrame, borderPadding); 
+
+  PRInt32 colX;
+  // availWidth is used as the basis for percentage width columns. It is aComputedWidth
+  // minus table border, padding, & cellspacing
+  nscoord availWidth = aComputedWidth - borderPadding.left - borderPadding.right - 
+                       ((mNumCols + 1) * mTableFrame->GetCellSpacingX());
+  
+  PRInt32 specifiedCols = 0;  // the number of columns whose width is given
+  nscoord totalColWidth = 0;  // the sum of the widths of the columns 
+
+  nscoord* colWidths = new PRBool[mNumCols];
+  nsCRT::memset(colWidths, -1, mNumCols*sizeof(nscoord));
 
   // for every column, determine it's specified width
-  for (colIndex = 0; colIndex<mNumCols; colIndex++)
+  for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) { 
-  { 
     // Get column information
-    nsTableColFrame *colFrame = mTableFrame->GetColFrame(colIndex);
+    nsTableColFrame* colFrame = mTableFrame->GetColFrame(colX);
-    NS_ASSERTION(nsnull!=colFrame, "bad col frame");
+    NS_ASSERTION(nsnull != colFrame, "bad col frame");
 
     // Get the columns's style
     const nsStylePosition* colPosition;
     colFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)colPosition);
 
-    // Get fixed column width if it has one
+    // get the fixed width if available
-    if (eStyleUnit_Coord==colPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) 
+    if (eStyleUnit_Coord == colPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) { 
-    {
+      colWidths[colX] = colPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue();
-      nscoord colWidth = colPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue();
+    } // get the percentage width
-      mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colIndex, colWidth);
+    else if (eStyleUnit_Percent == colPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) { 
-      totalWidth += colWidth;
+      float percent = colPosition->mWidth.GetPercentValue();
-      specifiedColumns++;
+      colWidths[colX] = NSToCoordRound(percent * (float)availWidth); 
-      autoWidthColumns[colIndex]=PR_FALSE;
-      if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
-        printf ("from col, col %d set to width %d\n", colIndex, colWidth);
     }
-    else
+    else { // get width from the cell
-    {
+      nsTableCellFrame* cellFrame = mTableFrame->GetCellFrameAt(0, colX);
-      nsTableCellFrame *cellFrame = mTableFrame->GetCellFrameAt(0, colIndex);
+      if (nsnull != cellFrame) {
-      if (nsnull!=cellFrame)
-      {
         // Get the cell's style
         const nsStylePosition* cellPosition;
         cellFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)cellPosition);
 
-        // Get fixed column width if it has one
+        PRInt32 colSpan = mTableFrame->GetEffectiveColSpan(colX, cellFrame);
-        if (eStyleUnit_Coord==cellPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) 
+        // Get fixed cell width if available
-        {
+        if (eStyleUnit_Coord == cellPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) {
-          PRInt32 colSpan = mTableFrame->GetEffectiveColSpan(colIndex, cellFrame);
+          colWidths[colX] = cellPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue() / colSpan;
-          nscoord effectiveWidth = cellPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue()/colSpan;
+        }
-          mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colIndex, effectiveWidth);
+        else if (eStyleUnit_Percent == cellPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) {
-          totalWidth += effectiveWidth;
+          float percent = cellPosition->mWidth.GetPercentValue();
-          specifiedColumns++;
+          colWidths[colX] = NSToCoordRound(percent * (float)availWidth / (float)colSpan); 
-          autoWidthColumns[colIndex]=PR_FALSE;
-          if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
-              printf ("from cell, col %d set to width %d\n", colIndex, effectiveWidth);
         }
       }
     }
+    if (colWidths[colX] >= 0) {
+      totalColWidth += colWidths[colX];
+      specifiedCols++;
+      if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug) printf ("col %d set to width %d\n", colX, colWidths[colX]);
+    }
   }
-  
+ 
-  // for every column that did not have a specified width, compute its width from the remaining space
+  nscoord lastColAllocated = -1;
-  if (mNumCols > specifiedColumns)
+  nscoord remainingWidth = availWidth - totalColWidth;
-  {
+  if (tableIsFixedWidth && (0 < remainingWidth)) {
-    // Get the table's style
+    if (mNumCols > specifiedCols) {
-    const nsStylePosition* tablePosition;
+      // allocate the extra space to the columns which have no width specified
-    mTableFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)tablePosition);
+      if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("%p: remainingTW=%d\n", mTableFrame, remainingWidth);
-    if (eStyleUnit_Coord==tablePosition->mWidth.GetUnit())
+      nscoord colAlloc = NSToCoordRound( ((float)remainingWidth) / (((float)mNumCols) - ((float)specifiedCols)));
-    {
+      for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) {
-      nscoord specifiedTableWidth = tablePosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue();
+        if (-1 == colWidths[colX]) {
-      nscoord remainingTableWidth = specifiedTableWidth - totalWidth;
+          colWidths[colX] = colAlloc;
-      if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
+          totalColWidth += colAlloc; 
-        printf ("%p: specifiedTW=%d, remainingTW=%d\n", 
+          lastColAllocated = colX;
-                mTableFrame, specifiedTableWidth, remainingTableWidth);
+          if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("auto col %d set to width %d\n", colX, colAlloc);
-      if (0<remainingTableWidth)
-      {
-        nscoord widthPerColumn = remainingTableWidth/(mNumCols-specifiedColumns);
-        for (colIndex = 0; colIndex<mNumCols; colIndex++)
-        {
-          if (PR_TRUE==autoWidthColumns[colIndex])
-          {
-            mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colIndex, widthPerColumn);
-            totalWidth += widthPerColumn; 
-            if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
-              printf ("auto col %d set to width %d\n", colIndex, widthPerColumn);
-          }
         }
       }
     }
+    else { // allocate the extra space to the columns which have width specified
+      float divisor = (float)totalColWidth;
+      for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) {
+        if (colWidths[colX] > 0) {
+          nscoord colAlloc = NSToCoordRound(remainingWidth * colWidths[colX] / divisor);
+          colWidths[colX] += colAlloc;
+          totalColWidth += colAlloc; 
+          lastColAllocated = colX;
+          if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("col %d set to width %d\n", colX, colWidths[colX]);
+        }
+      }
+    }  
   }
-  // min/MaxTW is max of (specified table width, sum of specified column(cell) widths)
+
-  mMinTableWidth = mMaxTableWidth = totalWidth;
+  nscoord overAllocation = (availWidth >= 0) 
-  if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
+    ? totalColWidth - availWidth : 0;
-    printf ("%p: aMinTW=%d, aMaxTW=%d\n", mTableFrame, mMinTableWidth, mMaxTableWidth);
+  // set the column widths
+  for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) {
+    if (colWidths[colX] < 0) 
+      colWidths[colX] = 0;
+    // if there was too much allocated due to rounding, remove it from the last col
+    if ((colX == lastColAllocated) && (overAllocation != 0)) {
+      colWidths[colX] += overAllocation;
+      colWidths[colX] = PR_MAX(0, colWidths[colX]);
+    }
+    mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colX, colWidths[colX]);
+  }
+
+  // min/max TW is min/max of (specified table width, sum of specified column(cell) widths)
+  mMinTableWidth = mMaxTableWidth = totalColWidth;
+  if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("%p: aMinTW=%d, aMaxTW=%d\n", mTableFrame, mMinTableWidth, mMaxTableWidth);
 
   // clean up
-  if (nsnull!=autoWidthColumns)
+  if (nsnull != colWidths) {
-  {
+    delete [] colWidths;
-    delete [] autoWidthColumns;
   }
   
   return PR_TRUE;

layout/html/table/src/FixedTableLayoutStrategy.h

@@ -72,7 +72,7 @@ protected:
     * @return PR_TRUE if all is well, PR_FALSE if there was an unrecoverable error
     *
     */
-  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths();
+  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aComputedWidth);
 
 
 };

layout/html/table/src/nsITableLayoutStrategy.h

@@ -32,8 +32,9 @@ public:
   /** call once every time any table thing changes (content, structure, or style) 
     * @param aMaxElementSize  [OUT] if not null, the max element size is computed and returned in this param
     * @param aNumCols         the total number of columns in the table
+    * @param aComputedWidth   the computed size of the table
     */
-  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols)=0;
+  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols, nscoord aComputedWidth)=0;
 
   /** compute the max-element-size for the table
     * @param aMaxElementSize  [OUT] width field set to the min legal width of the table

layout/html/table/src/nsTableFrame.cpp

@@ -2497,7 +2497,7 @@ NS_METHOD nsTableFrame::Reflow(nsIPresContext& aPresContext,
       if (nsnull!=mTableLayoutStrategy)
       {
         if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug || PR_TRUE==gsDebugIR) printf("TIF Reflow: Re-init layout strategy\n");
-        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount());
+        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
         mColumnWidthsValid=PR_TRUE; //so we don't do this a second time below
       }
     }
@@ -2506,7 +2506,7 @@ NS_METHOD nsTableFrame::Reflow(nsIPresContext& aPresContext,
       if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug || PR_TRUE==gsDebugIR) printf("TIF Reflow: Re-init layout strategy\n");
       if (nsnull!=mTableLayoutStrategy)
       {
-        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount());
+        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
         mColumnWidthsValid=PR_TRUE;
       }
     }
@@ -3972,17 +3972,22 @@ void nsTableFrame::BalanceColumnWidths(nsIPresContext& aPresContext,
             this, maxWidth, aMaxSize.width, aMaxSize.height);
 
   // based on the compatibility mode, create a table layout strategy
-  if (nsnull==mTableLayoutStrategy)
+  if (nsnull == mTableLayoutStrategy) {
-  {
     nsCompatibility mode;
     aPresContext.GetCompatibilityMode(&mode);
     if (PR_FALSE==RequiresPass1Layout())
       mTableLayoutStrategy = new FixedTableLayoutStrategy(this);
     else
       mTableLayoutStrategy = new BasicTableLayoutStrategy(this, eCompatibility_NavQuirks == mode);
-    mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aMaxElementSize, GetColCount());
+    mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aMaxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
     mColumnWidthsValid=PR_TRUE;
   }
+  // fixed-layout tables need to reinitialize the layout strategy. When there are scroll bars
+  // reflow gets called twice and the 2nd time has the correct space available.
+  else if (!RequiresPass1Layout()) {
+    mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aMaxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
+  }
+
   mTableLayoutStrategy->BalanceColumnWidths(mStyleContext, aReflowState, maxWidth);
   mColumnWidthsSet=PR_TRUE;
 

layout/tables/BasicTableLayoutStrategy.cpp

@@ -233,7 +233,8 @@ BasicTableLayoutStrategy::~BasicTableLayoutStrategy()
 }
 
 PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, 
-                                            PRInt32 aNumCols)
+                                            PRInt32 aNumCols,
+                                            nscoord aMaxWidth)
 {
 #ifdef NS_DEBUG 
   nsIFrame* tablePIF = nsnull; 
@@ -251,7 +252,7 @@ PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize,
   mCols            = mTableFrame->GetEffectiveCOLSAttribute();
 
   // Step 1 - assign the width of all fixed-width columns
-  AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths();
+  AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(aMaxWidth);
 
   // set aMaxElementSize here because we compute mMinTableWidth in AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths
   if (nsnull != aMaxElementSize) {
@@ -389,7 +390,7 @@ nscoord BasicTableLayoutStrategy::CalcHorizontalPadding(PRInt32 aColX)
 
 // Step 1 - assign the width of all fixed-width columns, all other columns get there max, 
 //          and calculate min/max table width
-PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths()
+PRBool BasicTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aMaxWidth)
 {
   TDBG_SP("** %p: AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths **\n", mTableFrame);
   nsVoidArray *spanList    = nsnull;

layout/tables/BasicTableLayoutStrategy.h

@@ -91,7 +91,7 @@ public:
     * @param aMaxElementSize  [OUT] if not null, the max element size is computed and returned in this param
     * @param aNumCols         the total number of columns in the table
     */
-  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols);
+  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols, nscoord aMaxSize);
 
   /** compute the max element size of the table.
     * assumes that Initialize has been called
@@ -123,10 +123,12 @@ protected:
     * Computes the minimum and maximum table widths. 
     * Set column width information in each column frame and in the table frame.
     *
+    * @param aMaxWidth - the computed width of the table or 
+    *  UNCONSTRAINED_SIZE if an auto width table
     * @return PR_TRUE if all is well, PR_FALSE if there was an unrecoverable error
     *
     */
-  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths();
+  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aComputedWidth);
 
   /** compute the min and max width of this table.  Assumes AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths
     * has been called.  Sets mMinTableWidth and mMaxTableWidth as a side effect.

layout/tables/FixedTableLayoutStrategy.cpp

@@ -73,109 +73,135 @@ PRBool FixedTableLayoutStrategy::BalanceColumnWidths(nsIStyleContext *aTableStyl
   return result;
 }
 
-/* assign the width of all columns
+/*
+ * assign the width of all columns
  * if there is a colframe with a width attribute, use it as the column width
  * otherwise if there is a cell in the first row and it has a width attribute, use it
  *  if this cell includes a colspan, width is divided equally among spanned columns
  * otherwise the cell get a proportion of the remaining space 
  *  as determined by the table width attribute.  If no table width attribute, it gets 0 width
  */
-PRBool FixedTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths()
+PRBool FixedTableLayoutStrategy::AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aComputedWidth)
 {
+  NS_ASSERTION(aComputedWidth != NS_UNCONSTRAINEDSIZE, "bad computed width");
   if (gsDebug==PR_TRUE) printf ("** %p: AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths **\n", mTableFrame);
-  
-  PRInt32 colIndex;
-  PRInt32 specifiedColumns=0;   // the number of columns whose width is given
-  nscoord totalWidth = 0;       // the sum of the widths of the columns whose width is given
 
-  PRBool * autoWidthColumns = new PRBool[mNumCols];
+  const nsStylePosition* tablePosition;
-  nsCRT::memset(autoWidthColumns, PR_TRUE, mNumCols*sizeof(PRBool));
+  mTableFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)tablePosition);
+  PRBool tableIsFixedWidth = eStyleUnit_Coord   == tablePosition->mWidth.GetUnit() ||
+                             eStyleUnit_Percent == tablePosition->mWidth.GetUnit();
+
+  const nsStyleSpacing* tableSpacing;
+  mTableFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Spacing, (const nsStyleStruct*&)tableSpacing);
+  nsMargin borderPadding;
+  tableSpacing->CalcBorderPaddingFor(mTableFrame, borderPadding); 
+
+  PRInt32 colX;
+  // availWidth is used as the basis for percentage width columns. It is aComputedWidth
+  // minus table border, padding, & cellspacing
+  nscoord availWidth = aComputedWidth - borderPadding.left - borderPadding.right - 
+                       ((mNumCols + 1) * mTableFrame->GetCellSpacingX());
+  
+  PRInt32 specifiedCols = 0;  // the number of columns whose width is given
+  nscoord totalColWidth = 0;  // the sum of the widths of the columns 
+
+  nscoord* colWidths = new PRBool[mNumCols];
+  nsCRT::memset(colWidths, -1, mNumCols*sizeof(nscoord));
 
   // for every column, determine it's specified width
-  for (colIndex = 0; colIndex<mNumCols; colIndex++)
+  for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) { 
-  { 
     // Get column information
-    nsTableColFrame *colFrame = mTableFrame->GetColFrame(colIndex);
+    nsTableColFrame* colFrame = mTableFrame->GetColFrame(colX);
-    NS_ASSERTION(nsnull!=colFrame, "bad col frame");
+    NS_ASSERTION(nsnull != colFrame, "bad col frame");
 
     // Get the columns's style
     const nsStylePosition* colPosition;
     colFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)colPosition);
 
-    // Get fixed column width if it has one
+    // get the fixed width if available
-    if (eStyleUnit_Coord==colPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) 
+    if (eStyleUnit_Coord == colPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) { 
-    {
+      colWidths[colX] = colPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue();
-      nscoord colWidth = colPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue();
+    } // get the percentage width
-      mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colIndex, colWidth);
+    else if (eStyleUnit_Percent == colPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) { 
-      totalWidth += colWidth;
+      float percent = colPosition->mWidth.GetPercentValue();
-      specifiedColumns++;
+      colWidths[colX] = NSToCoordRound(percent * (float)availWidth); 
-      autoWidthColumns[colIndex]=PR_FALSE;
-      if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
-        printf ("from col, col %d set to width %d\n", colIndex, colWidth);
     }
-    else
+    else { // get width from the cell
-    {
+      nsTableCellFrame* cellFrame = mTableFrame->GetCellFrameAt(0, colX);
-      nsTableCellFrame *cellFrame = mTableFrame->GetCellFrameAt(0, colIndex);
+      if (nsnull != cellFrame) {
-      if (nsnull!=cellFrame)
-      {
         // Get the cell's style
         const nsStylePosition* cellPosition;
         cellFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)cellPosition);
 
-        // Get fixed column width if it has one
+        PRInt32 colSpan = mTableFrame->GetEffectiveColSpan(colX, cellFrame);
-        if (eStyleUnit_Coord==cellPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) 
+        // Get fixed cell width if available
-        {
+        if (eStyleUnit_Coord == cellPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) {
-          PRInt32 colSpan = mTableFrame->GetEffectiveColSpan(colIndex, cellFrame);
+          colWidths[colX] = cellPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue() / colSpan;
-          nscoord effectiveWidth = cellPosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue()/colSpan;
+        }
-          mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colIndex, effectiveWidth);
+        else if (eStyleUnit_Percent == cellPosition->mWidth.GetUnit()) {
-          totalWidth += effectiveWidth;
+          float percent = cellPosition->mWidth.GetPercentValue();
-          specifiedColumns++;
+          colWidths[colX] = NSToCoordRound(percent * (float)availWidth / (float)colSpan); 
-          autoWidthColumns[colIndex]=PR_FALSE;
-          if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
-              printf ("from cell, col %d set to width %d\n", colIndex, effectiveWidth);
         }
       }
     }
+    if (colWidths[colX] >= 0) {
+      totalColWidth += colWidths[colX];
+      specifiedCols++;
+      if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug) printf ("col %d set to width %d\n", colX, colWidths[colX]);
+    }
   }
-  
+ 
-  // for every column that did not have a specified width, compute its width from the remaining space
+  nscoord lastColAllocated = -1;
-  if (mNumCols > specifiedColumns)
+  nscoord remainingWidth = availWidth - totalColWidth;
-  {
+  if (tableIsFixedWidth && (0 < remainingWidth)) {
-    // Get the table's style
+    if (mNumCols > specifiedCols) {
-    const nsStylePosition* tablePosition;
+      // allocate the extra space to the columns which have no width specified
-    mTableFrame->GetStyleData(eStyleStruct_Position, (const nsStyleStruct*&)tablePosition);
+      if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("%p: remainingTW=%d\n", mTableFrame, remainingWidth);
-    if (eStyleUnit_Coord==tablePosition->mWidth.GetUnit())
+      nscoord colAlloc = NSToCoordRound( ((float)remainingWidth) / (((float)mNumCols) - ((float)specifiedCols)));
-    {
+      for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) {
-      nscoord specifiedTableWidth = tablePosition->mWidth.GetCoordValue();
+        if (-1 == colWidths[colX]) {
-      nscoord remainingTableWidth = specifiedTableWidth - totalWidth;
+          colWidths[colX] = colAlloc;
-      if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
+          totalColWidth += colAlloc; 
-        printf ("%p: specifiedTW=%d, remainingTW=%d\n", 
+          lastColAllocated = colX;
-                mTableFrame, specifiedTableWidth, remainingTableWidth);
+          if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("auto col %d set to width %d\n", colX, colAlloc);
-      if (0<remainingTableWidth)
-      {
-        nscoord widthPerColumn = remainingTableWidth/(mNumCols-specifiedColumns);
-        for (colIndex = 0; colIndex<mNumCols; colIndex++)
-        {
-          if (PR_TRUE==autoWidthColumns[colIndex])
-          {
-            mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colIndex, widthPerColumn);
-            totalWidth += widthPerColumn; 
-            if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
-              printf ("auto col %d set to width %d\n", colIndex, widthPerColumn);
-          }
         }
       }
     }
+    else { // allocate the extra space to the columns which have width specified
+      float divisor = (float)totalColWidth;
+      for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) {
+        if (colWidths[colX] > 0) {
+          nscoord colAlloc = NSToCoordRound(remainingWidth * colWidths[colX] / divisor);
+          colWidths[colX] += colAlloc;
+          totalColWidth += colAlloc; 
+          lastColAllocated = colX;
+          if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("col %d set to width %d\n", colX, colWidths[colX]);
+        }
+      }
+    }  
   }
-  // min/MaxTW is max of (specified table width, sum of specified column(cell) widths)
+
-  mMinTableWidth = mMaxTableWidth = totalWidth;
+  nscoord overAllocation = (availWidth >= 0) 
-  if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug)
+    ? totalColWidth - availWidth : 0;
-    printf ("%p: aMinTW=%d, aMaxTW=%d\n", mTableFrame, mMinTableWidth, mMaxTableWidth);
+  // set the column widths
+  for (colX = 0; colX < mNumCols; colX++) {
+    if (colWidths[colX] < 0) 
+      colWidths[colX] = 0;
+    // if there was too much allocated due to rounding, remove it from the last col
+    if ((colX == lastColAllocated) && (overAllocation != 0)) {
+      colWidths[colX] += overAllocation;
+      colWidths[colX] = PR_MAX(0, colWidths[colX]);
+    }
+    mTableFrame->SetColumnWidth(colX, colWidths[colX]);
+  }
+
+  // min/max TW is min/max of (specified table width, sum of specified column(cell) widths)
+  mMinTableWidth = mMaxTableWidth = totalColWidth;
+  if (PR_TRUE == gsDebug) printf ("%p: aMinTW=%d, aMaxTW=%d\n", mTableFrame, mMinTableWidth, mMaxTableWidth);
 
   // clean up
-  if (nsnull!=autoWidthColumns)
+  if (nsnull != colWidths) {
-  {
+    delete [] colWidths;
-    delete [] autoWidthColumns;
   }
   
   return PR_TRUE;

layout/tables/FixedTableLayoutStrategy.h

@@ -72,7 +72,7 @@ protected:
     * @return PR_TRUE if all is well, PR_FALSE if there was an unrecoverable error
     *
     */
-  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths();
+  virtual PRBool AssignPreliminaryColumnWidths(nscoord aComputedWidth);
 
 
 };

layout/tables/nsITableLayoutStrategy.h

@@ -32,8 +32,9 @@ public:
   /** call once every time any table thing changes (content, structure, or style) 
     * @param aMaxElementSize  [OUT] if not null, the max element size is computed and returned in this param
     * @param aNumCols         the total number of columns in the table
+    * @param aComputedWidth   the computed size of the table
     */
-  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols)=0;
+  virtual PRBool Initialize(nsSize* aMaxElementSize, PRInt32 aNumCols, nscoord aComputedWidth)=0;
 
   /** compute the max-element-size for the table
     * @param aMaxElementSize  [OUT] width field set to the min legal width of the table

layout/tables/nsTableFrame.cpp

@@ -2497,7 +2497,7 @@ NS_METHOD nsTableFrame::Reflow(nsIPresContext& aPresContext,
       if (nsnull!=mTableLayoutStrategy)
       {
         if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug || PR_TRUE==gsDebugIR) printf("TIF Reflow: Re-init layout strategy\n");
-        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount());
+        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
         mColumnWidthsValid=PR_TRUE; //so we don't do this a second time below
       }
     }
@@ -2506,7 +2506,7 @@ NS_METHOD nsTableFrame::Reflow(nsIPresContext& aPresContext,
       if (PR_TRUE==gsDebug || PR_TRUE==gsDebugIR) printf("TIF Reflow: Re-init layout strategy\n");
       if (nsnull!=mTableLayoutStrategy)
       {
-        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount());
+        mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aDesiredSize.maxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
         mColumnWidthsValid=PR_TRUE;
       }
     }
@@ -3972,17 +3972,22 @@ void nsTableFrame::BalanceColumnWidths(nsIPresContext& aPresContext,
             this, maxWidth, aMaxSize.width, aMaxSize.height);
 
   // based on the compatibility mode, create a table layout strategy
-  if (nsnull==mTableLayoutStrategy)
+  if (nsnull == mTableLayoutStrategy) {
-  {
     nsCompatibility mode;
     aPresContext.GetCompatibilityMode(&mode);
     if (PR_FALSE==RequiresPass1Layout())
       mTableLayoutStrategy = new FixedTableLayoutStrategy(this);
     else
       mTableLayoutStrategy = new BasicTableLayoutStrategy(this, eCompatibility_NavQuirks == mode);
-    mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aMaxElementSize, GetColCount());
+    mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aMaxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
     mColumnWidthsValid=PR_TRUE;
   }
+  // fixed-layout tables need to reinitialize the layout strategy. When there are scroll bars
+  // reflow gets called twice and the 2nd time has the correct space available.
+  else if (!RequiresPass1Layout()) {
+    mTableLayoutStrategy->Initialize(aMaxElementSize, GetColCount(), aReflowState.computedWidth);
+  }
+
   mTableLayoutStrategy->BalanceColumnWidths(mStyleContext, aReflowState, maxWidth);
   mColumnWidthsSet=PR_TRUE;